Peters Criticizes Trump’s “Undiplomatic” UN Remarks

During a recent speech at the United Nations General Assembly, US President Donald Trump criticized the organization, calling comments by New Zealand’s Foreign Affairs Minister Winston Peters “undiplomatic.” Trump’s remarks focused on the recognition of a Palestinian state by various UN member countries, which he claims rewards Hamas and undermines efforts for peace.

In his address, Trump condemned the ongoing humanitarian crisis in Gaza, which has escalated since the conflict erupted on October 7, 2023. He specifically referenced the surprise attack by Hamas on Israel that resulted in the deaths of approximately 1,195 people and the kidnapping of around 250 individuals. Following Israel’s military response, casualties in Gaza have reportedly exceeded 65,000.

Trump’s Critique of the UN

Trump articulated his frustration with the UN, questioning its effectiveness. “What is the purpose of the United Nations?” he asked a packed assembly hall. He emphasized that while the UN has “tremendous potential,” it often fails to act decisively. “All they seem to do is write a really strongly worded letter and then never follow that letter up,” he stated. “It’s empty words, and empty words don’t solve war. The only thing that solves war and wars is action.”

After the speech, Peters responded to inquiries about Trump’s comments. He remarked, “I don’t go and make undiplomatic comments like that.” Peters acknowledged that if the UN is to be more effective, it must focus on critical modern issues and spend its resources wisely. “On all three counts, the answer is they need to do better, yes,” he added.

In his speech, Trump also claimed to have “ended seven unendable wars” and expressed his commitment to achieving a ceasefire in the ongoing conflict. He criticized the UN’s consideration of recognizing a Palestinian state, suggesting it would reward Hamas for its actions, including the events of October 7. “The rewards would be too great for Hamas terrorists, for their atrocities,” Trump asserted, urging UN members to prioritize the release of hostages taken by Hamas.

Peters’ Perspective on Hostage Release

Peters, who was present in the assembly hall during Trump’s speech, chose to reserve his reflections on the implications of Trump’s comments until he has heard from other world leaders throughout the week. He did, however, emphasize the importance of prioritizing the release of hostages, stating, “Who could possibly argue about that?” He acknowledged the gravity of the situation and the moral imperative to advocate for the hostages taken during the October 7 events.

As discussions continue at the UN, Peters remains non-committal regarding the New Zealand government’s stance on Palestinian recognition. He indicated that the diverse views expressed by various nations present provide valuable insights. “We’re pleased to be hearing all these different views. You’ll see that they’re widely different from different countries in the world,” he stated. “Our job is to ensure that one of the world’s oldest democracies has a position of integrity, and that’s what we’re going to do.”

The UN General Assembly remains a critical platform for addressing global issues, and Trump’s remarks have sparked a range of reactions, highlighting the complexities surrounding international diplomacy and conflict resolution.