Government Responds to McSkimming Report with New Oversight Measures

An investigation into the handling of complaints against former Deputy Police Commissioner Jevon McSkimming has led the New Zealand government to announce significant reforms. The report, released by the Independent Police Conduct Authority (IPCA), highlights critical failures by former Police Commissioner Andrew Coster and other senior officials in addressing serious allegations against McSkimming, who resigned in May 2023.

The IPCA’s findings reveal that police officials delayed referring a woman’s complaints to the authority, despite recommendations to do so. Additionally, it alleges that senior police attempted to influence the investigation process, raising concerns about integrity and accountability within the police force. Coster, who became Police Commissioner in 2020, has since transitioned to the role of chief executive of the Social Investment Agency and indicated last July that he would not seek a second term.

In response to the report, Police Minister Mark Mitchell expressed his disappointment with the previous police executive’s decision-making, highlighting significant flaws that have undermined public trust. “Their actions have raised serious concerns about integrity and culture within the then executive,” Mitchell stated, emphasizing the need for the highest standards of integrity in policing.

The report identifies a woman as having been “let down by the former police executive and the system.” This sentiment resonates with the government’s commitment to implementing robust oversight mechanisms. Minister Chris Collins announced that the government will establish the position of Inspector General of Police, aiming to provide stronger statutory oversight.

The report also raised questions regarding the Public Service Commission‘s (PSC) vetting process when McSkimming was appointed Deputy Police Commissioner in 2023. Concerns about the sufficiency of independent oversight were highlighted, with Collins acknowledging that New Zealanders will naturally have questions about McSkimming’s qualifications for high-level roles within the police.

The IPCA made a total of 13 recommendations for police reforms and two for government oversight. Collins confirmed that all recommendations have been accepted, stating, “It is imperative New Zealanders have confidence in our police.” The government is committed to ensuring that such failures do not recur.

Mitchell added that the police have agreed to strengthen integrity and conduct processes, revise the code of conduct to mandate reporting of misconduct, and enhance integrity training. He praised those within the police force who demonstrated moral courage during these challenging circumstances, asserting that the report’s findings should not reflect negatively on the police service as a whole.

The government’s decisive actions aim to restore public confidence and ensure accountability within the New Zealand police system.